This one is in memory of Walter Koenig (Pavel Chekov in the original series) and Sir Patrick Stewart (Jean-Luc Picard in The Next Generation), both of whom we lost recently. Rest in peace...


You could say that Captain Kirk & Co. from the original Star Trek walked so that the cast and crew of Star Trek: The Next Generation could run, but let's be real here: The Next Generation had everything: Higher production values, expanded (and actually adhered to!1) lore and universe, and quite frankly, a more seasoned and diplomatic lead in Picard. Not to mention, by this point in Next Gen's run, the show has become something outside of its lead actors. Early on, they absolutely tried to swap out Kirk, Spock, and McCoy for Picard, Riker, and Data, but eventually learned that this series had a really colorful cast of characters around them as well. The audience wanted more of the other characters, and Next Gen eventually started delivering it as a true ensemble... For better or worse.

Hey, before we get going too much further, just a quick note! This is the latest installment of my massive Star Trek rewatch and review project. If you're interested in reading my previous reviews about the original series, animated series, their six films, and the first four seasons of Next Gen, you can head over to my “Complete Collection” page that I've set up just so I could keep it all organized! You can also follow me on Bluesky where I sometimes post while watching live or just get up to other silly shenanigans. Who knows where it'll go?!

The fifth season cast of Star Trek: The Next Generation.

Picking up right where the fourth season dropped us off, The Next Generation's fifth season opener is “Redemption, Part II.” After receiving Worf's resignation, Captain Picard and the Enterprise vacate the region in their best efforts to avoid getting the Federation further involved in a potential civil war in the Klingon Empire. Rather than fully abandoning Worf and the Klingons, however, Picard is aware that the Romulans could gain the upper-hand if their interference is successful, so he decides to form a Federation blockade between Romulan and Klingon space. This causes the blonde Romulan commander that we saw at the very end of the previous season to contact the Enterprise and arrange a meeting with Picard. During this meeting, she introduces herself as Commander Sela and explains that her familiarity to the crew is due to the fact that former security chief Tasha Yar was her mother.2 Fully aware the inconsistency in timelines, Sela feels compelled to tell Picard that he himself had unknowingly sent Tasha back in time with the Enterprise-C during the alternate timeline of events presented in the third season episode “Yesterday's Enterprise,” altering the main timeline where Tasha survived and apparently bore a child shortly after being captured by the Romulans. Fed up with Picard's meddling, Sela informs him that he needs to call off the blockade, or they will attack.

Captain Picard eventually turns to Gowron, the Klingon he helped to name Chancellor, and asks that he take care of the sisters. Gowron knows that aligning themselves with the Romulans will ultimately destroy any support that the Duras family has raised for Toral. Meanwhile, Data, who has been given temporary command of the U.S.S. Sutherland in the fleet, indicates to the other Federation ships that he has found a way to trace the source of a network disruption back to the cloaked Romulan forces, who he then fires torpedoes at, causing them to retreat. Worf, who had been held captive by Lursa and B'Etor, is able to free himself and capture Toral, but the sisters escape. Gowron gives Worf the opportunity to kill Toral, but Worf declines because the entire conflict was started by his aunts. He then returns to the Enterprise to be reinstated.

This two-part story had a lot of Klingon and Romulan conflict, which as I mentioned in my previous review, I was not particularly interested in. Worf and Picard's involvement aside, I feel like they could have done something different with Denise Crosby's return. Tasha Yar having a baby due to the timeline mishap in season three is interesting stuff, but we don't really spend enough time with Sela to see it pay off much. Lursa and B'Etor are also pretty fun villains, but again, we don't see a ton of them until the Generations film. In fact, my favorite part of these episodes is when Dpablata takes command of the Sutherland and puts his first officer in place when he asks to transfer to a different ship as he harbors prejudice against Data as an android. Data states that he understands his misgivings, but then declines his transfer. It's a great scene to watch.

Thankfully, the fifth season goes on to showcase some other really fantastic episodes. It becomes obvious by this point that the show has definitely hit its stride. If season three was where Next Gen came into its own, and the fourth season was finding its footing, then this season is essentially hit after hit. The infamous episode, “Darmok,” is the very next episode after the second part of “Redemption.” Considered one of the series' very best, this episode sees the Enterprise rendezvousing with an alien species called the Tamarians, who had been in contact with the Federation previously but were unable to communicate. The ship's universal translator is capable of translating the words they are saying, but the order and manner of their words couldn't be understood. Dathon, the Tamarian captain, decides to have himself and Picard transported down to a planet's surface and orders his officers to enable a field to prevent any further transportation beams. On the surface, Dathon keeps saying the phrase, “Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra.” He also passes a dagger to Picard, who initially believes Dathon wants to fight, which he outright refuses. Shortly after the two realize that there is some sort of creature on the planet who might prey on them, Picard realizes that the reason they cannot communicate with one another is because the Tamarians speak only in metaphor and allegory; they refer to their stories and history as a means to communicate. Beginning to understand the story of Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra as a story in which two strangers meet and become friends after taking on an impossible challenge, Picard comes to see Dathon as friendly. However, when it actually comes time to face the creature on the planet, Dathon is mortally wounded and passes with Picard sharing with him a similar story to comfort him.

Captain Picard (Sir Patrick Stewart) asking his crew for suggestions.

Picard is eventually rescued from the planet by the Enterprise after the crew disables the Tamarian transporter field. Once aboard, he interrupts the hostilities between Riker and Dathon's first officer to inform them, in their own way of speaking, that Dathon had perished. In turn, they ask that Picard keep Dathon's dagger as a way of remembering him, and refer to the event as, “Picard and Dathon at El-Adrel.”

The third episode of the season introduces a recurring character who would become very popular with the audience: Ensign Ro Laren, a Bajoran woman with an extremely prickly personality played by actress Michelle Forbes. Created by the writers as a character who would occasionally cause friction between the main cast of characters, she would also step onto the bridge as a conn officer to sometimes serve as a replacement for Wesley. She was also initially created with the intention of her move to the spinoff, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, though Forbes eventually declined to appear on that series.3 In this episode, also titled “Ensign Ro,” it fills us in on Ro's remarkable backstory, but the actual plot of her assisting Picard in apprehending a Bajoran terrorist isn't too memorable. They're successful in the mission, and despite being expected to go back to her previous posting, Ro eventually earns Picard's respect and willingly transfers to the Enterprise.

The two-part episodes, “Unification, Part I” and “Unification, Part II,” fall around mid-season this year. In an attempt to reunify the Vulcans with their distant Romulan cousins, Spock, who has seemingly defected to Romulus, comes into contact with Captain Picard and Lt. Commander Data. When I finally got to these episodes, I couldn't help but think how funny it was that Leonard Nimoy was reprising the role of Spock here, since creator Gene Roddenberry originally had an issue with the new series touching on characters or events from the original series, and with the exception of DeForest Kelley's cameo in the pilot episode of Next Gen, they had mostly toed that line in their early years. Now here's Spock, fully integrated into the cast as a guest star. Despite their best efforts, they're unable to achieve reunification between the two worlds after they are sold out to none other than Commander Sela. The episode is also worth mentioning as having achieved among some of the best ratings Next Gen had during its entire run since Spock's appearance was smartly aired and marketed during the lead-up to Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country's theatrical release. These episodes also get something of a spiritual successor many hundreds of years later4 in the 31st century in the Star Trek: Discovery episode “Unification, Part III.”

There are several other amazing episodes this season, which I might wind up listing among my favorite seasons of the series overall, including “Disaster,” an episode that easily could have been nothing more than a bottle episode, but actually winds up taking some interesting and unexpected turns; “The Game” and “The First Duty,” two episodes that see Wesley Crusher returning in guest starring capacity; “Cause and Effect,” which sees the Enterprise being destroyed over and over again as the crew realizes they've become trapped in a time loop; “Cost of Living,” in which Lwaxana Troi returns to the Enterprise and takes an unsuspecting Alexander under her wing, despite Worf's misgivings; “I, Borg,” the episode that introduces Hugh, an injured young Borg drone that the crew treats and restores a sense of individuality to; and, of course, “Time's Arrow, Part I,” in which Data's severed head is discovered underneath San Francisco near Starfleet Headquarters, puzzlingly having been placed there some 500 years prior. It also serves as the fifth season finale, with the second part opening next season.

More specifically, one episode that I want to bring particular attention to is just before the finale. It's another episode that has changed my opinion this rewatch. I never really had any particular complaints about it but I also never really thought much about it. I used to think it was kind of a boring character piece and was always more excited to watch the episodes before and after. I was also always confused why I would see other fans and publications list it among some of the greatest episodes of Star Trek ever made. That episode is “The Inner Light,” an otherwise universally beloved episode centered on Picard living an entirely separate life on another world. It starts out like any other installment of Next Gen, honestly. The crew of the Enterprise comes into contact with an alien probe which scans the ship and somehow renders Picard unconscious. When he wakes up, he is on the surface of a planet he has never heard of called Kataan. Not only has he woken up in an unfamiliar location, but a woman who is caring for him named Eline and his best friend Batai keep referring to him by the name Kamin. The people of this planet also dismiss his stories of commanding a starship as fever dreams, and eventually, Picard simply starts living his life as Kamin. He has children, studies the stars, and learns to play the flute. He and Eline grow old together.

Due to extreme planetary drought conditions, Kamin learns that Kataan's sun will soon go nova. He does his best to bring this before the government, but they admit that they have known this information for some time, and have not released it to the public in order not to cause panic. They admit that there is nothing they can do, since they still have very primitive technology, and would never be able to vacate the population in time. Instead, the people of Kataan place their memories into a space probe to inform those who eventually come across it what life on their world was like, and Picard realizes that this is exactly what has happened to him.

Dr. Crusher finally revives Picard on the Enterprise. They inform him that only 25 minutes had apparently passed since he was knocked out, despite the fact that he feels and can still recall perfectly that he had lived an entirely different life. While he was unconscious, the crew trace the probe's trajectory back to a system whose inhabitants had gone extinct from the aforementioned sun going nova more than 1,000 years ago. At the end of the episode, Riker informs Picard that the probe had been brought on board the Enterprise, but it had already ceased transmission. They found a box containing Kamin's flute inside, however, and Picard decides to keep it. Once Riker leaves his quarters, Picard begins to play a song he had learned during his time on Kataan.

As an elder millennial, I had viewed this episode before and found it sorta boring. Upon rewatching as an older adult, specifically one who has lost several loved ones in my time, I have a much better appreciation for it. The thought of a doomed species not sending out a distress call or panicking to get off the planet but instead sending out the story and knowledge of their existence is incredibly heartbreaking, especially since we are discovering it so long after they were already gone. Experiencing a whole different lifetime among these people must also have made that grief even more palpable for Picard. Keeping the flute on his desk throughout the remainder of Next Gen, some of the films, and even many years later on Star Trek: Picard is also a poignant reminder of one of the more delicate events the man has seen himself through, and one that Sir Patrick Stewart performed stunningly in. Now I understand why it's considered the best episode of Next Gen, and even the entire franchise. The episode got a lot of acclaim as well, and even became the first episode of Star Trek overall to be nominated for Best Dramatic Presentation at the Hugo Awards since the original series' “The City on the Edge of Forever.”

The U.S.S. Enterprise-D leaving Spacedock.

The only question now is just how the show is going to manage to top this season with only two left?? We'll have to see in the next review! 🖖